Best Places for Pizza in New York City

It’s hard to find a bad slice in this town. But these spots do it better than the rest.

It is difficult to go anywhere in New York without discovering a pizza place; the locals know what they like. Though there are many opportunitiesto help yourself to a tasty slice, not every location warrants a memorable meal. New York is world renowned for its pizza and some of it isn’t exaggerated.The city is filled traditional pizza making families who work religiously to ensure they live up to the name, from Manhattan to Brooklyn these artists practice both traditional Neapolitan methods and other, more experimental pizzas. There is a pizza for everybody whether you are on a tight budget or have cash to spare at these of the top picks for the best pizza in New York.

Circa Brewing Co.

A downtown Brooklyn location with a deceptively impressive beer hall, decked with shiny stainless steel fermenting tanks you can bet that the owners have spared no expense. The décor is equally impressive with large glass blocks and clean cut concrete giving a postmodern yet early industrial vibe to the whole experience. Tasty Traditional Pizzas in a nice environment warrants an enjoyable meal, a particular favourite is the Hawaiian for its tangy pineapple and delicious spirit soaked ham.

You can find this location at:
141 Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Di Fara

This pizza joint is well established and has remained consistent throughout its current lifetime, it is one of the most costly but pleasantly surprising places in the city enabling an entire pie to be purchased for around $30.00. The owner produces every result personally and has done since the business’ birth over fifty years ago. You will find all the basic ingredients like basil, olive oil and tasty tomatoes with the added touch of handcrafted personality. Worth trying out if you’ve got the dough.

You can find this location at:
1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230, USA

Emmy Squared

A high quality square that offers Detroit-style pizza and can give any competitor a run for their money, like many of the previous entry in this list, Emmy Squared is packed with tasty toppings to pepper on the decadently cheesy surface of a practically perfect pizza. Chillies, pepperoni, honey are among some of the more popular ingredients. This dazzling square also has a secret underside that serves burgers and sandwiches too for those you fancy a change.

You can find this location at:
364 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Joe and Pat’s

This isolated little diamond in the rough ca be found on Staten Island and acts as a local landmark. Despite the distance/difficulty to get to you will most certainly experience the benefit once there due to its impressively high quality pizzas and beautiful interior design. Perfectly balanced crusts and toppings accompanied with a cloud painted ceiling make this one of the best places to go, if you are looking for a fine dining experience involving pizza.

You can find this location at:
Staten Island, NY, United States

Joe’s Pizza

This particular provider is considered to be a famouscraftsman of the purest example of pizza from New York. The interior is red bricked and cluttered with photograph and furniture in a charming blend of home-like family feeling and effective customer service. Though place is better suited to those looking for a quick munch as opposed to a sit down meal as the location even comes accompanied with stand up benches.

You can find this location at:
7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014, USA

John’s of Times Square

Located in one of the busiest places in the entire world this pizza joint is an independent business from the originator on Bleecker Street. The building is large in size and can accommodate a large number of hungry customers, the church like aesthetic of the interior makes the entire dining experience feel magical as your eyes always have something interesting to look at (particularly the stained glass images). An interesting feature of this business is the don’t deal in half measures…literally. This pizza joint’s big brick oven only provides complete pizzas and not lonely slices. It is probably for the best that you try this out in large group or with a huge appetite.

You can find this location at:
260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

John’s of Bleecker Street

This particular location has done wonderful things with pizza for over a century, the staff work routine is competently executed and they aren’t stingy with their ingredients. This is a tasty treat for those who aren’t looking a complex arrangement and more for a simple classic.

You can find this location at:
278 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, USA


A high quality provider of pizza just like you’d find in the likes of any city in Italy. The owner is a trained artist when it comes to classic Neapolitan pizzas, Roberto Caporuscio has travelled all they way to New York to make his own personal impression on the network of pizzerias among its streets. This location is quintessential example of Italian Pizza making with an impression and diverse collection of ingredients such as prosciutto di Parma and San Marzano tomatoes. Delicious.

You can find this location at:
271 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, USA

Lil’ Frankie’s

This place is pretty well rounded when it comes to their traditional piazzas, they don’t particularly stand out as pioneers of Italian Cuisine but offer good quality just the same. The results from the kitchen of consistent and simple, using a customized brick oven their products are filled with tasty, bubbling, soft-cheesed pizza with hearty helpings of fresh basil and salami. If there is one thing that can be said about Lil’ Fankies, they certainly aren’t stingy when it comes to their pizzas.

You can find this location at:
19 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10003, USA


This restaurant is owned by a self taught craftsman who is local to the area, his recipes originate from his grandmother’s instruction and a staple of Brooklyn: Dom DeMarco of Di Fara”s who gave him the inspiration for some of his dishes. The place is popular and has a no reservation policy meaning the seats are rarely empty, if you ever consider a trip down to this little gem you should set off early to insure that you are seated on time.

You can find this location at:
575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA


A contemporary take on modern and youthful dining, opting for thin crust and smaller portions you can really feel the classy elegance of well designed location. This particular place is impressive for its wide and interesting range of appetizers such as fried risotto croquettes. The choice in pies is more interactive and customizable than most other pizza joints.

You can find this location at:
198 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003, USA

Motorino Pizzeria

This location sparks interest from a retroactive crowd that embodies the season of change, you will see many families and unique looking individuals with a range of hip and trendy outfits to old fashioned attire. Good old Neapolitan pies that know how to fill a stomach are served here with the standard assortment of toppings available. You can’t fault a tasty helping of spiced garlic or pancetta so get yourself down early.

You can find this location at:
139 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11211, USA

Pasquale Jones

This place offers a welcome respite to all of the down to earth locations that you may find commonplace in New York city. With refreshingly clean cut almost minimalistic interior design you will find little to distract you from your food. With a more contemporary atmosphere you would expect the pizza to be equally progressive and modern, this however is not the case as thankfully the owner has chosen to keep the pizzas simple and traditional, perfection.

You can find this location at:
187 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012, USA

Patsy’s Pizzeria

One of the original Pizza places on the block, a New York institution with the added benefit of grabbing yourself a slice on the move. It is a genuine, all out taste adventure through good old fashioned methods of pizza crafting. This location has remained faithful to the old ways without forfeiting it’s decent quality. If you want to taste the twentieth century this is the place for you.

You can find this location at:
2287 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10035, USA

Paulie Gee’s

The first thing that you will notice about this Neapolitan style restaurant is that its atmosphere is warm and inviting, with the dull rumble of pleasant conversation and happy munching you will find it difficult to resist Paulie Gee’s charm. The originality that is displayed on the plate uses unique ingredients and combinations to blow your taste buds away. The use of pastrami and Canadian bacon is absolutely divine along with an assortment of cheeses including mozzarella, gorgonzola and prosciutto. For the eagle eyed among you, you may notice a secret pizza option at the back of the menu that should try at least once.

You can find this location at:
60 Greenpoint Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, USA

Prince Street Pizza

Now this is a pizzeria that’s pushing the envelope, a popular location with hip and interesting food choices such a square pepperoni and the option to remove the frills from your slice. Splashing on a host of tasty ingredients including stringy mozzarella and a tongue tingling choice of red sauce. You can even get a slice of pizza to go if you are in a rush or busy exploring the streets of New York.

You can find this location at:
27 Prince St A, New York, NY 10012, USA


This location is a landmarked testament to retroactive interior design, this yet another pizza joint with a great big oven that certainly knows how to use it. This is a nice, friendly charming location with white-washed brick walls that will make you feel at ease as you kick back the a pint of your favourite beer. Definitely worth checking out, especially in the winter months when you ca see the giant oven in its full glory.

You can find this location at:
261 Moore St, Brooklyn, NY 11206, USA


Most pizza places take great pride in their equipment, Sottocasa is not an exception. They brought a huge oven all the way from Naples weighing a monstrous two tons, after realizing this was too large for the interioran incrediblelarge scale operation wasexecuted to elevate the oven over the building using a crane and then install it in the backyard. Themethods and techniques used by the owner of this Italian run location were honed and perfected at anotherpizzeriain New York calledKestè, based on this knowledge it is clear that Sottocasa’sclassicallyprepared pizzas bare some merit. This pizza joint assuresfresh, high quality ingredientsare used so watery mouthedcustomers can rest easySottocasa Pizza will excel in flavour and texture boastingolive oil from Sicily, good old fashioned tomatoes and Fior di Latte Mozzarella.

You can find this location at:
298 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Speedy Romeo

Another Brooklyn entry on this list shaped like a corner store with a decent local history, it feels industrial and working class in the best way possible. All of the rough materials combined with an interesting color scheme make this a feast for both the eyes and the stomach. The wood fuelled oven is also a nice tough that further contributes to this gritty display of human achievement. A tasty combination of cheeses and toppings are available for your pizza here including béchamel, ricotta and parmesan.

You can find this location at:
63 Clinton St, New York, NY 10002, USA
So if your stomach grumbles for a taste of Italy/NewYorkwhy not give any of the places a try? They are all worth a taste and every cent paid.

So hurry up and visit the New York City with OurBus having various services from Binghampton to NYC, Ithaca to NYC or Boston to NYC and explore these awesome pizza places!

You Might Also Like

No Comments

Leave a Reply